On Thursday, 12/12/2019, Asst .Prof. Dr. Manal Raafat Khaled from the College of Tourism Sciences, Mosul University, participated in the discussion committee of the Doctoral student Faten Ghani Mahmoud , Mosul University, College of Education for Pure Sciences for her thesis entitled (Elements of Agricultural Development in Halabja Province) . The discussion committee was headed by Prof.Dr. Abdul Karim Rashid Abdul Latif and included each of Asst. Prof. Dr. Ali Abed Abbas Al- Azzawy , Prof . Dr . Lamia Hussein Ali , Asst .Prof. Dr. Manal Raafat Khaled , Asst. Prof. Dr. Mohammad Hashem Thanoon as members , the thesis supervised by Prof.Dr. Khalid Ali Akbar. At the end of the discussion it was announced that the student received a doctorate degree. Congratulations to the student ,the supervisor, and the members of the discussion committee.